Daniel Suescun-Diaz, Geraldyne Ule-Duque, Jesus Antonio Chala-Casanova

Corresponding email: daniel.suescun@usco.edu.co

Corresponding email: daniel.suescun@usco.edu.co

**Published at : ** 28 Jul 2023

**Volume :** **IJtech**
Vol 14, No 5 (2023)

**DOI :** https://doi.org/10.14716/ijtech.v14i5.5970

Suescun-Diaz, D., Ule-Duque, G., Chala-Casanova, J.A., 2023. Nuclear Reactivity Calculation with Reduction of Fluctuations.

670

Daniel Suescun-Diaz | Department of Exact and Natural Sciences, Surcolombiana University, Neiva, 410001, Colombia |

Geraldyne Ule-Duque | Department of Exact and Natural Sciences, Surcolombiana University, Neiva, 410001, Colombia |

Jesus Antonio Chala-Casanova | Department of Exact and Natural Sciences, Surcolombiana University, Neiva, 410001, Colombia |

Abstract

This article presents a study
based on a series of numerical experiments. It demonstrates the possibility of
reducing fluctuations in the calculation of reactivity using the second
Bernoulli number based on the approximation of the Euler-Maclaurin formula.
This approach requires knowledge of the first three derivatives, which are
implemented progressively. The fluctuations are assumed to occur around an
average value of the neutron density with a Gaussian distribution. Jitter
reduction is performed with a first-order delayed low-pass filter for different
forms of neutron population density, with different time steps and with
different filter constants. The numerical results show that the method can be
used as a digital reactivity meter.

Inverse point kinetics equation; Neutron population density; Numerical experiment; reactivity; Second Bernoulli number

Introduction

The increasing world population has led to a higher
demand for electrical energy in recent years. As a critical component of
supporting a country's economic growth (Saroji
*et al.*, 2022), the electric power
system plays a crucial role in meeting this demand. An alternative path would
be to provide a solution where home automation systems can reduce electricity
consumption (Rabbani and Foo, 2022). Another viable option is urban wind energy which is one of the new renewable
ways of producing electricity; however, researchers have not studied very much
in this field (Krasniqi, Dimitrieska, and Lajqi, 2022). Nuclear energy is another
viable option obtained through nuclear reactors. However, it is necessary to
know the reactivity parameters with good accuracy in nuclear reactors to
operate a nuclear power plant more safely. Therefore, one of the main functions
of a nuclear power plant is to control and monitor reactivity (Hyvarinen *et al.*, 2022).

In recent decades, different experimental and
computational methods have been developed to estimate the reactivity value in
the core of a nuclear reactor. Studies have been carried out in a BAEC TRIGA
Mark- II research reactor to analyze the effects of reactivity insertion, as
well as in a prototype fast breeder reactor Monju (Hossain
*et al.*, 2022; Ohgama *et al.*, 2022). The results are validated by a deterministic model given by the Inhour
equation and the Monte Carlo method. The *in-hour equation* is also used
in estimating reactivity in experiments conducted in the light water reactor at
the VENUS-II experimental facility (Jiang *et al.*, 2022).

Solving the inverse point kinetics equation provides a mathematical model that allows the calculation of reactivity. This method is commonly employed in computer-based simulations and facilitates the development of digital reactivity meters. To apply this model, the neutron density is required as an input, which can be measured using devices like ionization chambers (Vasilenko, Pankin, and Skvortsov, 2019). Studies that take this perspective are being conducted in the context of the decommissioning of the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant. This includes a preliminary analysis that identifies the range that applies to the MIK code, such as ramped reactivity insertion (Fukuda, Nishiyama, and Obara, 2021).

A method has been developed to correct reactivity
values by accounting for changes in both the neutron flux function and detector
efficiency (Zhitarev *et al.*, 2021). Based on an analysis of the inverse point kinetics equation, the
influence of the background current on the measured reactivity is analyzed and
a method for iterative calculation of reactivity is introduced (Huo *et al.*, 2019). An
accurate numerical solution for the inverse point kinetics equation is given
using the discrete Fourier transform (Suescun-Diaz, Lozano-Parada,
and Rasero-Causil, 2019). The extended Kalman filter technique (Bhatt *et
al.*, 2013) and the wavelet-based
multiscale extended Kalman filter technique have also been proposed for
reactivity estimation (Patel Mukhopadhyay,
and Tiwari, 2018).
However, reactivity meters based on the inverse point kinetics equation have
sufficient capabilities to accurately estimate reactivity (Shimazu, 2014).

Due to gamma radiation, electronic system noise, and
environmental radiation, there is considerable noise in the electrical current
during reactivity measurement by external detectors, which leads to significant
reactivity error, especially at low powers (Huo *et
al.*, 2019). Under these noise conditions,
it is necessary to apply a filtering tool to smooth or reduce the fluctuations
in the measurements.

In the present work, we study the approximation to
solve the integral in the inverse point kinetic equation using the Euler-Maclaurin formula (Arfken, Weber, and Harris, 2013), which
provides a powerful connection between integrals and sums, considering the approximation of the second
Bernoulli number, with the combination using the first-order delayed low-pass
filter to reduce fluctuations in the reactivity calculation. The results
indicate that it is an alternative method for reactivity calculation with good
approximation and can be used to design a digital reactivity meter.

Experimental Methods

*2**.**1**. Theoretical
Considerations* The point kinetics equations are a set of differential equations that
describe the time evolution of the expected values of the neutron density and
the concentration of delayed neutron precursor groups in the core of a nuclear
reactor. These equations accurately describe the reactor core dynamics and
correspond to the time component of the neutron diffusion equation under the
assumption of an isotropic and homogeneous medium (Stacey,
2018). They are described as follows:

where, *P(t) *is the neutron density, *C _{i}(t) *is
the concentration of the i-th group of delayed neutron precursor, is the reactivity, is the neutron generation time, is the i-th fraction of delayed neutrons,

Solving for from equation (1) leads to the following reactivity equation:

The unknown term in equation (5) is the concentration of precursors *C _{i}(t)*, which can be found by solving equation (2) by an integrating factor or by
the Laplace transform -considering equations (3) and (4)- will lead to the
following expression:

By replacing equation (6) with equation (5), a new equation for reactivity
is obtained, which needs all the values of the neutron density to be known:

Equation (7) is the so-called inverse point kinetic
equation and allows the calculation of the nuclear reactivity, which provides
information on the behavior of a reactor core. This equation has been a model
that has been applied in the design of digital reactivity meters that
contribute significantly to the control and safe operation of a nuclear
reactor. However, its dependence on all the values of the neutron density in a
non-recursive way causes a high computational cost, which makes it difficult to
calculate the reactivity in real-time. To reduce the computational cost, the
following section presents a method that discretizes the integral containing
the dependence on the neutron density by using the Euler-Maclaurin formula with
an approximation of two Bernoulli numbers.

*2.2. Proposed Method*

To achieve greater accuracy in
reactivity calculations while minimizing computational costs, it is necessary
to discretize the integral term in equation (7). This is accomplished by
applying the Euler-Maclaurin formula as follows (Kwok,
2010):

where the term *B _{k}* represents the
Bernoulli numbers.

Substituting equation (8) into
equation (7), reactivity with the approximation of the first Bernoulli number *B _{1}=1/6
*is obtained (Suescun-Diaz, Ule-Duque,
and Pena-Lara, 2020). To find a descriptive expression for reactivity with the approximation
of the second Bernoulli number

Being the time step in
the reactivity computation, *n* indicates the discrete-time, and its
relation to the continuous time is is the
system response to a unit impulse function (Haykin,
2014) defined here as

Replacing equation (9) into equation (7), the
following expression for reactivity is obtained:

Equation (10) represents the reactivity with the
approximation of the first two Bernoulli numbers, being the correction of the first Bernoulli number represented in equation (12), and the correction with the second Bernoulli number represented in the equation
(13).

For the calculation of the first, second and third
derivatives, the progressive derivatives are implemented (Mathews and Fink, 2005) as given
by equations (14-16):

where*et al.*, 2000), which is given by the expression:

Where * *is the filtering constant.

There are 422 nuclear reactors in operation and
another 56 under construction with 377 872 MWe and 58 584 MWe total net
installed capacity, respectively. The reactivity value is critical for ensuring the
safe operation of nuclear reactors. Therefore, the objective of the proposed
method in this work is to numerically solve the inverse point kinetics equation
using equation (10). The low-pass filter given by equation (18) is proposed to
reduce the fluctuations of an input signal associated with neutron population
density measurements.

The simulations were implemented using the MATLAB
computational tool. The physical constants used in this work are due to the
interaction of neutrons with the combustible material * ^{235}U*.
These constants are the decay constant

Results and Discussion

The
physical parameters in this results section are considered as above for a
thermal reactor with * ^{235}U* fuel elements. The most outstanding
results obtained for different numerical experiments are presented using the
proposed method given by equation (10) and denoted by

It is necessary to know
the reactivity with high precision; however, in practice, the neutron
population density contains noise, which has a Gaussian distribution that
produces fluctuations or uncertainties in the reactivity calculation. To reduce
fluctuations, the first-order delay low-pass filter given by equation (18) with
a filtering constant of and is used. In all numerical experiments, the time step
varies in the interval *[0.001, 0.1] s, *and the standard
deviation is For the different derivatives of neutron
density represented in equations (11-13), the progressive derivatives are taken
(Mathews and Fink, 2005), represented by equations (14-16).

Table 1 shows the maximum
differences in reactivity in *pcm* (parts per hundred thousand) for a
neutron density of the form * *with a value of * *obtained from the *inhour
equation *that provides a reactivity of about *50* *pcm*. It is
possible to observe that for this reactivity value, the reduction of the
fluctuations (RF) is effective for any time step, obtaining a reduction above *50%*
for any case, although the most significant occurs when a constant filter and a time step are used, reaching a reduction of
*84.06%*. This significant reduction indicates that the uncertainty in the
reactivity value decreases. In other words, it increases the precision in the
calculation of the reactivity that would achieve greater control of the
reactor. This RF is calculated as follow:
This RF is calculated as shown in equation (19).

To
validate the results obtained with the proposed method for the exponential form
of neutron density, a time-step of is considered for the EM2F case.
The results show a maximum difference of 0.88 pcm. In a study by Suescun-Díaz, Lozano-Parada, and Rasero-Causil (2019) under the
same conditions, a maximum difference of 2.06 pcm was reported using the
discrete Fourier transform. These results clearly demonstrate that the EM2F
method yields the highest level of reduction.

**Table
1 **Maximum difference in reactivity

In order to be able to make decisions in the operation
of a nuclear reactor using control rods, the reduction of fluctuations is
presented in Figures 1 and 2, the reactivity for a form of neutron density with and* * without low-pass filter (EM2) and with a low-pass filter (EM2F) at a filter
constant of ,
respectively. It can be observed that when a first-order low-pass filter is
applied, the fluctuations are effectively reduced.

**Figure 1** Reactivity
for a neutron density , without low-pass filter

**Figure 2** Reactivity
for a neutron density with with low-pass filter

Table 2 considers the neutron density of the form , , which gives a reactivity of about *20* *pcm*.
It is evident that for time steps the reduction of
fluctuations with the proposed method is significant. The achieved reduction
ranges from *56.64 %* to *92.17 %*. In this numerical experiment, it
was found that the fluctuations are reduced even for a time step *,* reaching a minimum reduction of *56.64 %*.

**Table 2 **Maximum difference in reactivity